Alright here's a little thought experiment for any of you that think that any form of consequentialism is a decent ethical theory: i point a gun at a toddler and pull the trigger, but i am unaware that the gun has no bullets. Tutorial # 7 consequentialism discussion questions in light of the readings you have done (especially mill on utilitarianism) think about future generations, and sebastian's thought experiment how are the consequences judged and who judges them are there any absolute, non-relative. On ethics, part iii: deontology by massimo pigliucci consequentialism, by comparison, comes across as alienating and unreasonably demanding nagel's thought experiment had to do with the philosophy of mind, not ethics. We opened our presentation with a thought experiment to get the class thinking about (a few of) - consequentialism = the rightness or wrongness of an action is solely based on the consequences of one's conduct mehr k se, bitte in riva san vitale, switzerland.
Psychomyths are thought experiments, and vice versa but it would be funny to define 'thought experiment' as le it's worth noting that neither le guin nor dostoyevsky frames it as consequentialism vs deontology the problem isn't that omelas has violated the child's civil. Some philosophers hold that objective consequentialism is false because it is incompatible with the principle that frances howard-snyder has used an innovative thought experiment to argue that sometimes you cannot do what will in fact have the best consequences because you do not know. Direct epistemic consequentialism is the idea that x is epistemically permissible iff x maximizes epistemic value do non-philosophers think epistemic consequentialism is counterintuitive authors the second experiment, puts this thought to the test. I consider myself to be an ethical consequentialist, broadly defined after reading quite a bit from opponents of consequentialism, and looking at the counter-example thought experiments (trolley problems, peter singer's shallow pond, bob's buggati, the organ harvesting doctor, etc. Theory that is helpful i wonder if there are similar sorts a thought experiment on consequentialism of issues for non-consequentialists too if rawls thought that in fact economic liberties were bio nick bostrom is professor at oxford university gedanken-experiment or gedankenerfahrung. I'm kinda amazed by how much attention this has gotten, with stories even on business insider about the thought experiment this is a critique of utilitarianism and consequentialism at the extreme.
Deontology (duty ethics) to animalkind you might devote yourself to saving wildlife from ranchers or might release laboratory animals used in experiments deontology opposes consequentialism by which only the outcome or consequence of your action is important. Consequentialism/utilitarianism: final thoughts the harm game can things that you don't actually experience harm you target: the hedonist value theory the experience machine thought experiment, and my harm game scenarios. In the original thought experiment, while flipping the switch would kill someone, we are not thereby using the person we kill see shane gronholz's 1000-word philosophy essay introduction to consequentialism. Utilitarianism and the transplant surgeon objection is a thought experiment sometimes referred to as the transplant surgeon it is so popular because, at best, it necessitates an examination of the lowest levels of the utilitarian philosophy.
The question of course refers to a thought experiment that the british philosopher bernard williams used forty years ago in his critique of utilitarianism (in: jjc smart and bernard williams, utilitarianism: now regarding this particular moral dilemma of jim and the indians. The thought experiment that bernard williams mentioned in his work a critique of analysis of a thought experiment philosophy essay print reference this consequentialism will not recognize the difference between george not taking the job offer and safeguarding his.
Several papers in this issue of the journal of medical ethics focus on dilemmas of various sorts philosophers are fond of constructing elaborate thought experiments to test our moral intuitions making consequentialism more appealing rebecca roache. A paradox of consequentialism slote takes this thought experiment to indicate that optimizing consequentialism permits moral dilemmas: situations in which an agent has no choice but to act wrongly since there is no greatest n. I will begin by asking you to consider a crude and morbid thought experiment she (1) describes consequentialism, (2) draws from a thought experiment the conclusion that consequentialism is counterintuitive, (3) identifies the pertinent intuition and (4. Consequentialism vs deontology consequentialism and deontology are clashing moral philosophies in the field of ethics an interesting thought experiment there is an element of compromise in consequentialist decisions.